Hello Tomo-san, and GW friends! It looks we have a good homework assignment to transcribe Rose Room, but I'm a bit wondering if I should change the approach I kind of chose for transcribing.
1. Is it good to stick to a simple form (e.g., blues) and one key initially?
2. Is it good to try transcribing solos with a lot of tension notes initially?
3. Is it good to try transcribing non-guitar solos initially?
I'm not technically quite capable, and musically I'm not hearing all the notes easily. But a few months ago I started transcribing solos in some of GW videos (e.g., Blue Monk in QAP04 test level 2), then started transcribing Charlie Christian's Grand Slam, T-Bone's Got a Break Baby (first intro. chorus). Lately I am trying Sonny Rollins' Blue Seven (in Saxophone Colossus, one of the first jazz albums I got many years ago). I'm skipping fast phrases, and the tune and Sonny's solo has a lot of tension notes. I'm so far sticking to blues as I thought I should not try too many things, and I'm also transposing all to B flat if tunes are not in B flat as I thought I could see/compare different note choices from different solos more easily. I'm not trying to remember solos necessarily, but hoping I can have better ideas how to put notes together practically using familiar phrases. I would think any time I spend for transcribing is helpful in multiple ways, but some advice from Tomo-san and others for the subject is greatly appreciated! There may be good and bad things for what I am doing up to now (I hope I'm not doing all bad). I like Rose Room (CC's solo is really memorable) and want to try it maybe after Blue Seven.
Got long, sorry, and thank you all for reading.
Yuji
Thank you Yuji for this thread!
Yes! That song is really good!
Charlie Christian "Rose Room"
First try something simple...so blues is good! Once you can transcribe simple blues then you can try something a little more challenging. Jazz blues? Or more?
Pick comfortable medium tempo. Not too fast! Not too slow!
Pick any good melodic solo! Any solos that sounds good to you!
No need to do hard songs or very technical in harmony.
You can do guitar solo or vocal melody, trumpet or piano.
No need to limit...
Blue Monk melody... any melody to transcribe.
Good way to start!
Skip any fast solos. Or 16th notes.... pick simple one.
Good medium tempo.
Thanks so much for sharing!
Definitely you want to transcribe entire solo, all the notes!
Did you transcribe this solo? If not, you should do this!
https://tomovhxtv.vhx.tv/videos/fb-bb-blues-soloing-etude
Tomo