Sooo…
I woke up at 4:30am and couldn’t get back to sleep so I decided to practice for a while before going to work.
I was just practicing chromatic scale exercises when I realized I wasn’t even paying attention to the string noise I was making. I was just going through the motions.
So I tried to force myself to concentrate and practice with intention. I played the exercises slowly and tried to concentrate but no matter how slow I played I was still making excess string noise which was making me frustrated.
So I decided to try doing something different and started working on triads.
While practicing up and down the neck I was hitting wrong strings and muting strings that I was trying to let ring out.
Again my frustration got the best of me and I said ‘forget it’ and put the guitar down.
My question is…
‘What is the best way to practice when your concentration is lacking and you are making mistakes that frustrate you?’
Should you continue to try and practice or should you put the guitar down and try later?
The only problem is I might not have another chance to practice today so I wanted to at least get the basics in.
What do you think???
Great question! There is no one correct answer. Like this " You just cannot focus" First thing, do not do anything and think about it for a while. You need to work hard but don't push is by just force. Great effort is not only your doing thing but also you need to use your passion and understanding a lot of details. For me, I really love to practice "Chromatic Scale" so slowly and I pay a lot of attention because I want to perform my guitar really well so i know I need that detail fingerings and picking techniques not just because someone told me what to do. No one told me that. I discoverd by doing "chromatic scale" with my curiosity and beyond. Same as R 3 7 swing groove. I really want to my rhythm skills as highest quality so I did choose to practice R 3 7 Swing Groove. I can think about this topic more.
Thank you Rich for sharing this. Very important topic for guitar practice and mental health.
Tomo
Hi Rich, I think you could also be getting more advanced with understanding what good looks like and you have a lot of guitar knowledge now. So when you have an off day you really feel it. A suggestion I thought is also to appreciate that you’re listening is getting more sensitive which is progress. Your body I think is going to catch up when you keep practicing with intention. Maybe that time you had a little more string noise than you wanted but was you back straight? Was your thumb towards the center? String noise shouldn’t be only thing. You might not get everything right but you can appreciate the things you do well and recognize those along with what you notice that needs more development. And whenever you need confidence you can sight read. You’re so great at sight reading I’m amazed at how you do that. I remember your video
Hello there, Rich. Such a thought provoking post. I have felt your frustration. FWIW, I've heard the advice "Practice so slowly that it's impossible for you to make a mistake".
I listened to an interview with musician Chris Thile, whom you've likely heard of. He talked about listening to his own previous recording of a piece of classical music. He reaction was "how much I hated it. It sounded plodding, choppy, and un-musical". Whoa! A guy of that caliber is unhappy with his own progress? What can that mean for the rest of us? I think it means that everyone can (and maybe should?) feel some dissatisfaction with their own playing. It may be part of what drives us. Certainly, I think it means sometimes we need to get off our own back. How about giving yourself some credit for even getting up at 4:30 in the morning and practicing at all? How many of your friends do that?
Rich said: "I tried to force myself to concentrate and practice with intention."
Stanley Kubrick: "The truth of a thing is the feel of it, not the think of it".
Just a thought.
Thanks for those suggestions Jeff.
I will see if I can try and focus on things that I can concentrate on (like keeping my back straight) the next time I have a practice session like that. I might try that the next time I try to meditate and my concentration is lacking. Just try and focus on what you can.
Thanks Linda -
I wasn’t really getting DOWN on my playing yesterday.
I was getting frustrated by my inability to concentrate.
I know when I do go to the meditation center they emphasize trying to be ‘mindful’ of the sensations of your body for the entire day. It is much easier to do at the meditation center but there are still many hours that go by where my thoughts just run away and I am not being mindful. When I am at the center I have no where else to go and nothing else to do so all I can do is start again. When I am home I get frustrated and stop.
I don’t think I’ll ever stop playing guitar but I didn’t know how best to handle the times when I just can’t seem to be mindful.
It’s so wonderful to have a community that continues to inspire you to keep going!